Back to Blog
comparisoncraftmypdf

LightningPDF vs CraftMyPDF - Drag-and-Drop PDF API Comparison

Compare LightningPDF and CraftMyPDF for template-based PDF generation. Pricing, designer features, API capabilities, and performance analysis.

By LightningPDF Team ·

LightningPDF vs CraftMyPDF: Template-Based PDF Generation Showdown

Both LightningPDF and CraftMyPDF go beyond simple HTML-to-PDF conversion by offering visual template designers. But which platform is better for building production PDF workflows? Let's dive deep.

Overview

CraftMyPDF is a template-based PDF generation service with a drag-and-drop editor and REST API. You design templates visually, then populate them with data via API calls.

LightningPDF is a dual-engine PDF platform with a visual template designer, pre-built marketplace templates, batch API, and native Go fast path for sub-100ms generation.

Pricing Analysis

CraftMyPDF

  • Free: 50 PDFs/month
  • Basic: $29/month for 500 PDFs
  • Pro: $79/month for 2,500 PDFs
  • Business: $199/month for 10,000 PDFs
  • Enterprise: Custom pricing for 50,000+ PDFs

Effective cost: $0.02-$0.058 per PDF

LightningPDF

  • Free: 50 PDFs/month
  • Starter: $9/month for 2,000 PDFs
  • Pro: $29/month for 10,000 PDFs
  • Business: $99/month for 50,000 PDFs
  • Enterprise: $249/month for 150,000 PDFs

Effective cost: $0.002-$0.005 per PDF

Winner: LightningPDF is 2-3x cheaper at every paid tier and offers 4x more documents in the Starter plan ($49 for 2,000 vs $29 for 500).

Template Designer Comparison

CraftMyPDF Designer

  • Drag-and-drop interface: Place text boxes, images, shapes on canvas
  • Template variables: {{name}}, {{address}}, etc.
  • Conditional rendering: Show/hide elements based on data
  • Page management: Multi-page templates
  • Image uploads: Logos, backgrounds
  • Limitations:
    • No HTML/CSS support (proprietary JSON format)
    • Fixed layout only (no dynamic reflow)
    • Limited text formatting options
    • No marketplace (must build everything yourself)

LightningPDF Designer

  • Visual HTML/CSS editor: Design with standard web technologies
  • Template variables: {{variable}} syntax with JSON data
  • Full HTML/CSS support: Use any CSS framework (Tailwind, Bootstrap)
  • Dynamic layouts: Content reflows naturally
  • Template marketplace: 50+ pre-built templates (invoices, receipts, reports)
  • Component library: Reusable headers, footers, tables
  • Live preview: See changes instantly
  • Version control: Track template changes

Winner: LightningPDF offers more flexibility with HTML/CSS support and a marketplace of pre-built templates.

Performance Benchmarks

CraftMyPDF

  • Template rendering: 1-2 seconds per PDF
  • Single rendering engine
  • No fast path optimization
  • Async API available for large batches

LightningPDF

  • Dual engine:
    • Native Go: <100ms for simple templates (invoices, receipts)
    • Chromium: 1-3 seconds for complex HTML/CSS layouts
  • Automatic engine selection based on template complexity
  • Batch API: Generate 1000s of PDFs in one request
  • Playwright browser pool for consistent Chromium performance

Example: Generate 1,000 invoices

  • CraftMyPDF: 1,000-2,000 seconds (16-33 minutes)
  • LightningPDF: 80-100 seconds (1-2 minutes) via native engine

Winner: LightningPDF is 10-20x faster for typical transactional documents.

API Capabilities

CraftMyPDF API

curl https://api.craftmypdf.com/v1/create \
  -H "X-API-KEY: YOUR_API_KEY" \
  -d '{
    "template_id": "abc123",
    "data": {
      "name": "John Doe",
      "amount": 100
    }
  }' \
  -o output.pdf

Features:

  • Synchronous and asynchronous generation
  • Webhook notifications
  • PDF encryption
  • Custom fonts

LightningPDF API

# Simple generation
curl https://lightningpdf.dev/api/v1/generate \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer YOUR_API_KEY" \
  -d '{
    "template_id": "invoice-v2",
    "data": {"invoice_number": "INV-001"}
  }' \
  -o output.pdf

# Batch generation
curl https://lightningpdf.dev/api/v1/batch \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer YOUR_API_KEY" \
  -d '{
    "template_id": "invoice-v2",
    "data": [
      {"invoice_number": "INV-001"},
      {"invoice_number": "INV-002"}
    ]
  }' \
  -o invoices.zip

Features:

  • All CraftMyPDF features, plus:
  • Batch API: Generate 100-1000 PDFs in one call
  • Engine selection: Force native or Chromium engine
  • HTML fallback: Use raw HTML if template unavailable
  • Webhook metadata: Pass custom data through webhooks

Winner: LightningPDF has more advanced API features, especially batch processing.

Template Marketplace

CraftMyPDF

  • No template marketplace
  • Must design every template from scratch
  • Community templates: None officially provided
  • Example templates: A few basic demos in documentation

LightningPDF

  • 50+ pre-built templates:
    • Invoices (10+ styles)
    • Receipts (retail, restaurant, service)
    • Reports (financial, analytics, executive)
    • Certificates (completion, achievement, membership)
    • Contracts (NDA, service agreement, rental)
    • Labels (shipping, product, barcode)
  • One-click import to your account
  • Customize colors, fonts, logos
  • Save 10-40 hours per template

Winner: LightningPDF's marketplace is a massive time-saver for common PDF use cases.

Self-Hosting

CraftMyPDF

  • Cloud-only SaaS
  • No self-hosting option
  • Data processed on CraftMyPDF infrastructure

LightningPDF

  • Open core model:
    • Self-host on your infrastructure (Docker, Kubernetes)
    • Keep sensitive data in your VPC
    • Meet compliance requirements (HIPAA, GDPR, SOC2)
    • Customize rendering pipeline
    • Free for unlimited self-hosted documents
  • Cloud-hosted option available (easier, managed)

Winner: LightningPDF for enterprises needing data control and compliance.

Integration Examples

E-commerce: Order Invoices

CraftMyPDF:

  1. Design invoice template in drag-and-drop editor (2-4 hours)
  2. Test with sample data
  3. Integrate API call in order fulfillment flow
  4. Generate 1 PDF per order (2s each)

LightningPDF:

  1. Import "Professional Invoice" from marketplace (2 minutes)
  2. Customize logo and colors (5 minutes)
  3. Integrate API call in order fulfillment flow
  4. Generate 1 PDF per order (80ms each) via native engine

Time saved: 3.5 hours. Speed increase: 25x.

SaaS: Monthly Reports

CraftMyPDF:

  1. Design custom report template (4-8 hours)
  2. Make 1,000 individual API calls for 1,000 customers
  3. Wait 30+ minutes for all PDFs to generate
  4. Download and email each PDF separately

LightningPDF:

  1. Import "Analytics Report" template (2 minutes)
  2. Make 1 batch API call with 1,000 customer data objects
  3. Receive ZIP file with all 1,000 PDFs in 2 minutes
  4. Unzip and email (or use webhook to trigger emails)

Time saved: 7 hours + 28 minutes per month.

Use Case Recommendations

Choose CraftMyPDF if you:

  • Need a simple drag-and-drop PDF designer
  • Generate <500 PDFs/month
  • Don't need HTML/CSS flexibility
  • Prefer proprietary template format
  • Don't need batch processing
  • Want the absolute simplest learning curve

Choose LightningPDF if you:

  • Generate 1000+ PDFs/month at scale
  • Want sub-100ms generation for invoices/receipts
  • Need batch API for monthly report runs
  • Want to use standard HTML/CSS templates
  • Need pre-built marketplace templates
  • Require self-hosting for compliance
  • Value performance and cost efficiency
  • Want room to scale to millions of PDFs/month

Migration Guide

Moving from CraftMyPDF to LightningPDF:

Step 1: Template Migration

  • Export template design notes from CraftMyPDF
  • Search LightningPDF marketplace for similar template
  • Customize marketplace template or build new one with HTML/CSS
  • Test with sample data

Step 2: API Integration

  • Replace API endpoint: api.craftmypdf.com → lightningpdf.dev/api/v1/generate
  • Update auth header: X-API-KEY → Authorization: Bearer
  • Adjust request body (template_id + data same structure)
  • Test in staging environment

Step 3: Cutover

  • Run both APIs in parallel for 1 week
  • Compare PDF outputs for consistency
  • Switch traffic to LightningPDF
  • Monitor for issues

Most migrations complete in 2-4 hours.

Real-World Case Study

Scenario: B2B SaaS company generates 5,000 invoices/month

With CraftMyPDF

  • Cost: $79/month (Pro plan for 2,500) + $199/month (Business for 10k) = Need Business plan at $199/month
  • Time: 2s × 5,000 = 2.8 hours to generate all invoices
  • Template setup: 4 hours to design custom invoice
  • Batch support: None (5,000 individual API calls)

With LightningPDF

  • Cost: $29/month (Pro plan for 10,000 documents)
  • Time: 0.08s × 5,000 = 6.7 minutes to generate all invoices
  • Template setup: 5 minutes to import + customize marketplace template
  • Batch support: 1 API call generates all 5,000 as ZIP

Savings: Same cost, 25x faster, 48x less setup time.

Conclusion

Both CraftMyPDF and LightningPDF offer template-based PDF generation, but LightningPDF is the clear winner for modern applications:

  • 2-3x cheaper at every paid tier
  • 10-25x faster generation (native Go engine)
  • Template marketplace saves 10-40 hours per template
  • Batch API simplifies high-volume workflows
  • Self-hostable for compliance/data residency
  • HTML/CSS based (standard web technologies)

CraftMyPDF's drag-and-drop editor is simpler for absolute beginners, but LightningPDF's combination of marketplace templates, dual-engine performance, and batch processing make it the better choice for serious production workloads.

Start free with LightningPDF - 50 PDFs/month, access to full marketplace, no credit card required.

Ready to generate PDFs?

Start free with 50 PDFs per month. No credit card required.

Get Started Free